Gamification of the BIA Process

Posted on March 26, 2025 by Brent Huston

In an era where information security is more critical than ever, the hunt for innovative solutions to complex challenges is relentless. One such challenge is the Business Impact Analysis (BIA) process, which is pivotal in identifying potential impacts of disruptions on business operations. By incorporating gamification into this process, organizations can transform what is traditionally a dry procedure into an engaging, enlightening experience for employees.

BusinessIllustrated

Understanding the nuances of the BIA process starts with its foundational elements, aimed at assessing the potential impact on a business due to security breaches or other disruptions. When combined with gamification—an approach using game design elements in non-game contexts—information security processes can become more intuitive and motivating. This blend not only facilitates better training but also enhances awareness and responsiveness to security concerns.

This article delves into how gamification can revolutionize the BIA process, making it more interactive and effective. From teaching the CIA Triad through new interactive tools to tackling legal and regulatory obligations with creative problem-solving, we’ll explore how gamified approaches are setting new standards in cybersecurity. With case studies and insights from leaders like MicroSolved, we’ll present a comprehensive guide to enhancing the resilience and security of modern digital infrastructures.

The Basics of Business Impact Analysis (BIA)

A Business Impact Analysis (BIA) is a vital tool for businesses looking to protect themselves during unexpected events. By assessing potential risks, a BIA helps organizations maintain operations, even in emergencies. This process integrates risk management, disaster recovery, and business continuity planning. It prepares businesses to handle disruptions, whether they are natural disasters or cyber attacks. A well-structured BIA identifies how different disruptions might affect critical business functions, helping to minimize impacts. By doing so, it helps businesses stay on track toward their objectives, ensuring a robust business continuity plan is always in place.

Definition and Purpose

A Business Impact Analysis (BIA) is a strategic process designed to forecast the effects of disruptions on critical business processes. Its goal is to ensure business continuity in the face of unexpected incidents. Through a BIA, companies can swiftly recover from events like cyber attacks and power outages. The process involves risk assessments and planning for both business continuity and disaster recovery. By identifying vital processes and resources, a BIA sets the groundwork for a thorough analysis, enabling informed decisions on maintaining operations during challenging times.

Key Components of BIA

In a Business Impact Analysis, understanding potential threats is crucial. BIAs identify these threats and evaluate their impact on business operations. They also assess vulnerabilities in third-party vendors that could affect the business during disruptive events. An important aspect of a BIA is calculating downtime costs. This involves categorizing applications based on their severity levels, which allows for a clear recovery strategy. Furthermore, BIAs are essential in forming business continuity and disaster recovery plans. By pinpointing critical processes and resources, these plans ensure the business can continue core functions during upheavals. Another critical component is determining the maximum tolerable downtime. This concept helps shape recovery time and point objectives, ensuring quick and effective responses to disruptions.

Understanding Gamification in Information Security

In the world of information security, keeping employees engaged is crucial. One innovative way to accomplish this is through gamification. By integrating elements of gaming into training, organizations can enhance user engagement and understanding. This method transforms security policies and training into less burdensome activities. With gamification, employees are not just learning—they’re engaging in a dynamic, interactive way. Through this approach, security teams can maintain a culture of security awareness that is both sustainable and effective.

What is Gamification?

Gamification is a strategy that uses game-like elements in non-game settings. This includes contexts like employee training. The aim is to increase engagement and participation. Key elements often include rewards, points, and leaderboards. By introducing these fun aspects, security awareness programs become more engaging for employees. This approach not only makes learning more entertaining but also encourages better retention. Consequently, good practices are incentivized among employees. As threats and business needs evolve, gamification can adapt. This ensures training programs stay relevant and effective.

Benefits of Gamification in Security Processes

Gamification offers numerous benefits in security processes. It makes learning about security less of a chore and more engaging. Participants find the experience enjoyable, which in turn improves retention. By using gamified elements, organizations stimulate employee interest. This keeps their attention on understanding crucial security policies. Interactive methods such as simulations and role-playing are enhanced through gamification. These methods increase learning effectiveness and retention. Additionally, gamification supports the reinforcement of security practices. This is achieved through activities that captivate user attention using dynamic methods. Moreover, gamified training provides opportunities for recognition and rewards. This approach incentivizes employees to adopt and maintain good security practices, fostering a culture of ongoing awareness and vigilance.

Integrating Gamification into the BIA Process

Integrating gamification into the Business Impact Analysis (BIA) process enhances user engagement by making activities interactive and enjoyable. Gamification can improve the motivation and involvement of individuals taking part in BIA. Incorporating elements of gaming makes the process more appealing and easier to understand. This strategy helps strengthen the identification of critical business processes and resources. By doing so, it enhances the overall continuity strategy. Such engagement allows stakeholders to grasp business continuity and disaster recovery plans better. This ensures they’re more prepared for emergencies. The use of gamification incentivizes active participation and fosters a unified sense of responsibility and readiness among team members.

Enhancing Engagement Through Gamification

Gamification introduces gaming elements into non-game settings to boost engagement. This strategy keeps training sessions lively and effective through interactive approaches like simulations and role-playing. Implementing gamification can also be part of recognition and rewards programs. These programs aim to encourage good practices. Gamification ensures continued awareness by keeping participants interested through interactive methods. Additionally, using gamification in training programs updates learners on new threats, policies, and best practices engagingly.

Teaching the CIA Triad with Interactive Tools

Interactive tools are effective in teaching the CIA triad by aligning with corporate culture and using security awareness campaigns. Gamification methods in these tools can boost engagement by making learning more appealing. The CIA triad has evolved into a hexad, so tools should adapt to these changes. A solid understanding of information security frameworks is key when developing these interactive tools to align with organizational practices. Effective tools should include continual improvement practices, highlighting the need for iterative learning and assessment, ensuring that learners stay informed and adept at handling security tasks.

Bringing ISO 27001:2022 to Life

Effective adaptation to ISO 27001:2022 involves conducting a gap analysis to spotlight areas needing updates or new implementations. Organizations must revise their policies and procedures to reflect the latest updates of ISO 27001:2022. Implementing training programs is crucial for educating staff on new requirements, fostering a culture of security awareness. Tech platforms like ISMS.online help streamline compliance and continuous improvement. Regular communication with stakeholders about updates and changes is key, ensuring alignment and building trust within the organization. Engaging stakeholders through these updates helps institutions maintain a robust framework for security measures.

Identifying and Addressing Key Elements

Business Impact Analysis (BIA) is essential in Information Security, assessing processes, resources, and data assets to understand risks. The SIREN System provides a complete solution for conducting BIAs and risk assessments effectively. A key component of this process is understanding the potential threats and impacts on critical business functions. Social engineering audits help gauge employee security awareness and physical security measures, aligning practices with a culture of security awareness. Regular assessments and communication with key users uncover gaps between theory and reality. Developing continuity and recovery strategies based on BIA findings is vital for mitigating risks and ensuring service continuity. To maintain effectiveness, Business Continuity Plans (BCPs) must undergo regular testing through simulations or drills, pinpointing any weaknesses and ensuring that the plan remains updated.

Legal, Regulatory, and Contractual Obligations

Conducting a BIA helps businesses meet legal, regulatory, and contractual obligations. This is a major part of ISO 22301 standards. By identifying these obligations, companies can avoid regulatory fines and align with compliance requirements. The BIA process enforces controls to address legal gaps. As part of business continuity planning, recognizing these obligations ensures that companies develop a robust business continuity plan. This plan is vital for both internal audits and regulatory requirements.

Recognizing Application Dependencies

A BIA identifies dependencies between applications within an organization. Recognizing these is important. It uncovers risks associated with software as a service (SaaS) that rely on external dependencies. A failure in one application can disrupt others or critical business operations. Conducting a BIA allows businesses to manage these risks, ensuring smoother business operations. By understanding how new applications affect existing ones, organizations can adapt and improve their systems.

Resource Allocation and Prioritization

Defining the scope of an Information Security Management System (ISMS) influences how resources are allocated. This ensures alignment with risk assessment priorities. A comprehensive ISMS process uses tools for risk assessment and policy management, aiding in effective resource allocation. Business Impact Analyses help identify critical business processes, directing resource prioritization based on disruption impacts. By establishing recovery objectives like Recovery Time Objectives (RTOs) and Recovery Point Objectives (RPOs), companies can ensure resources are allocated to restore critical functions swiftly. A robust Business Continuity Plan demands resource allocation for action plan testing. This ensures readiness during real emergency events, supporting resilient business operations and informed decisions.

Calculating Downtime Costs

Calculating downtime costs is essential in any Business Impact Analysis (BIA). Downtime refers to the period when critical business functions are unavailable. For many businesses, this can lead to significant financial losses. A well-executed BIA examines potential threats and helps prioritize recovery strategies. This supports informed decisions on which areas require immediate attention and resources. By assessing the severity of different applications, companies can identify critical business operations and apply robust business continuity plans.

Methods for Calculating Costs

To calculate downtime costs, various methods are employed. Business Email Compromise (BEC) breaches cost around $50,000 per incident, while the median cost for ransomware is about $46,000. These figures highlight the need for comprehensive risk management. Businesses must consider their unique factors—such as customer base, revenue, and value at risk. Analyzing both maximum potential impacts and minimum likely losses gives a clearer understanding of potential financial risks. Documentation aids in risk management and ensures regulatory compliance, thereby reducing potential costs.

Using Gamification for Accurate Projections

Incorporating gamification into business continuity and risk management strategies can enhance accuracy. Gamification involves applying game-like elements—such as points and rewards—to educational contexts. Doing so increases engagement and retention among employees. This approach can be particularly effective for training security teams. By creating a culture of security awareness, businesses improve their response times to security incidents. Feedback mechanisms like quizzes help evaluate the success of these programs. By using interactive methods, businesses keep their workforce informed and better prepared to handle potential disruptions.

Enhancing Cybersecurity Measures

In today’s digital world, cybersecurity is crucial for protecting vital assets, systems, and data from threats. Implementing strong measures is essential to guard against unauthorized access and damage. An effective cybersecurity plan involves regular monitoring and testing to evaluate current defense strategies. This ongoing assessment helps in adjusting measures to maintain security. Incident response planning is also key. Strategies must be in place to tackle issues like cyberattacks swiftly. Collaboration with external partners, including government agencies and industry groups, enhances these efforts by sharing insights and best practices. Lastly, a thorough risk assessment identifies vulnerabilities within the digital system, aiding in the protection and resilience of infrastructure.

Developing Robust Risk Assessments

Developing comprehensive risk assessments is pivotal to securing digital assets and systems. The first step involves outlining the assessment’s scope, covering all digital elements and processes. Creating an inventory helps document each asset’s location, function, and importance. Identifying threats like natural disasters, cyberattacks, and hardware failures is another critical step. By understanding these potential risks, organizations can better protect their operations.

To enhance resilience, organizations should leverage expertise from industry associations and security consultants. These external resources bring valuable insights to the table. Additionally, it’s essential to keep risk assessment methodologies updated. As technology and business requirements evolve, so do threats and vulnerabilities. Regular reviews ensure that risk management strategies remain current and effective.

Preparing Disaster Recovery Plans

A well-prepared disaster recovery plan is vital for any organization relying on IT systems. Regular testing through simulations, tabletop exercises, or live drills helps identify any gaps. This continuous practice ensures the plan is updated and effective. Disaster recovery plans must be documented with all necessary details. This includes recovery strategies, critical contact information, and communication protocols. Storing this information securely both on and off-site is crucial for quick access during a crisis.

The effectiveness of a disaster recovery plan also depends on diverse perspectives. IT professionals focus on reducing downtime and data loss, while business stakeholders aim to protect customer service and finances. This collaborative approach enhances resilience, allowing timely restoration of critical IT systems and minimizing operational impacts. By incorporating risk assessment and business impact analysis, organizations can better prepare for potential threats and understand their effects on business operations.

Strengthening Digital Operational Resilience

In today’s digital world, protecting business operations against disruptions is essential. Strengthening digital operational resilience means keeping critical business functions running even during crises like cyberattacks, technical failures, or natural disasters. A robust resilience strategy lessens the damage from such incidents and keeps an organization’s reputation intact. Beyond protecting assets, digital resilience builds customer trust, ensuring that services continue smoothly even in tough times. Sharing insights and strategies with other organizations enhances security across the digital environment. Moreover, testing and training are crucial. Regularly evaluating Business Continuity Plans (BCP) and Disaster Recovery Plans (DRP) ensures they work effectively when needed. Such preparation readies organizations to handle emergencies efficiently.

Fortifying Against Potential Threats

Securing an organization against potential threats starts with regular risk assessments. These assessments identify and prioritize risks, setting the stage for effective security strategies. Building a culture of security awareness within an organization is important. Employees need to understand cybersecurity risks and learn best practices. Continuous monitoring plays a crucial role in detecting and managing threats. Organizations often use security operations centers for this purpose. Additionally, strong incident response and recovery plans help minimize damage from breaches, restoring normal operations quickly. Collaboration is also key. Partnering with industry peers and government bodies enhances knowledge-sharing. By pooling resources and threat intelligence, organizations can develop informed action plans and strengthen overall security frameworks.

Quantifying Human Risks with Gamification

Gamification is changing the way businesses approach security awareness. By integrating game elements into training, organizations make learning about security policies engaging. This approach transforms what can be a mundane process into an exciting one, increasing employee participation. Gamification keeps employees interested and boosts retention of security protocols. These interactive experiences are not just fun, they are effective. Studies show that gamified training leads to higher engagement and voluntary participation in security initiatives. Employees are more likely to remember and follow security measures when the learning process is enjoyable. By using games, organizations transform their culture of security awareness, making employees active participants in safeguarding the business.

Case Studies and Success Stories

Incorporating gamification into business processes has shown remarkable results across different industries. Hyundai transformed its innovation program, reducing rework by 57% with the SoftExpert Suite platform. Similarly, Raízen achieved impressive financial gains, projecting earnings of R$60 million with their ideas program using the same platform. In the realm of cybersecurity, SoSafe’s Human Risk Management platform uses gamified e-learning to boost engagement and instill better security practices. These success stories demonstrate how gamification can lead to tangible benefits like process efficiency, financial gains, and improved security awareness.

Leading Organizations Implementing Gamified BIA

Leading organizations are increasingly adopting gamified Business Impact Analysis (BIA) methods to handle complex datasets and ensure proper project scoping. Engaging senior management and stakeholders from the start enhances the effectiveness of a gamified BIA process. This involvement is crucial to set accurate recovery time objectives, aligning with the broader Business Continuity Plan (BCP). Through gamified strategies, businesses can develop robust continuity and recovery plans that support uninterrupted operations during disruptions. The process also encourages workforce participation, making the analysis more thorough and leading to better-informed decisions and a stronger culture of security awareness.

Measurable Outcomes and Benefits

Employing gamification in security training boosts employee engagement and retention by making learning both fun and educational. Regular assessments, such as quizzes and surveys, can pinpoint areas needing improvement, ensuring programs remain effective. Practical surveys and questionnaires can measure users’ security awareness levels by evaluating both theoretical understanding and real-life practices. By tracking participation rates, organizations can maintain high engagement levels, which is vital for robust information security. Recognition and rewards programs further incentivize employees to adhere to security policies, reinforcing desired behaviors and enhancing overall security frameworks.

Get More Info and Help from MicroSolved

MicroSolved offers expert guidance on improving your business’s security posture. They focus on helping organizations understand and manage potential security risks. Their team of security professionals aids in developing a culture of security awareness within companies.

Key Services Offered:

Security Incident Handling: Fast and effective response to security incidents to minimize impact.
Business Continuity Planning: Create robust business continuity plans to ensure critical business operations continue during disruptions.
Risk Management: Identify and manage potential threats to secure business objectives.

Benefits of Choosing MicroSolved:

Informed Decisions: Provide data-driven insights to make informed decisions about security strategies.
Regulatory Compliance: Ensure that security policies meet regulatory requirements through thorough internal audits.
Tailored Action Plans: Develop custom action plans to address specific business needs.

Service	Benefit
Security Incident Handling	Minimizes impact through prompt response times
Business Continuity Planning	Supports critical business functions during disruptions
Risk Management	Identifies potential risks for proactive management

MicroSolved empowers businesses to adopt robust security frameworks, ensuring comprehensive protection against potential impacts. For more detailed guidance, reach out to MicroSolved to enhance your business’s security operations.

* AI tools were used as a research assistant for this content.

Regulatory Requirements and Best Practices for Third-Party Network Configuration Reviews

Posted on February 3, 2025 by Brent Huston

The security of an organization’s network infrastructure is paramount.
Routers, switches, and wireless configurations serve as the backbone of enterprise networks, facilitating seamless
communication and data flow. However, if not properly configured and regularly assessed, these critical components
can become vulnerable entry points for cyber threats. Engaging third-party assessors to conduct regular configuration
reviews across global networks is not only a best practice but also aligns with various regulatory requirements.

ConfigRvw

Regulatory Mandates for Configuration Reviews

Several regulatory frameworks emphasize the importance of regular network configuration assessments:

National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST): The NIST Cybersecurity Framework highlights the necessity of maintaining secure configurations for network devices such as firewalls, routers, and switches. It advocates for regular assessments to ensure configurations align with security policies and standards.
Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS): PCI DSS Requirement 2 mandates that organizations “do not use vendor-supplied defaults for system passwords and other security parameters.” This underscores the need for secure configurations and regular reviews to prevent unauthorized access.
Center for Internet Security Critical Security Controls (CIS CSC) Version 8: Control 11 emphasizes the importance of “secure configuration for network devices,” recommending regular audits and the use of configuration management tools to maintain security standards.
Service Organization Control 2 (SOC 2): SOC 2’s Trust Services Criteria require organizations to implement controls to prevent unauthorized access, which includes maintaining and reviewing secure configurations of network devices.
Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA): HIPAA’s Security Rule mandates that covered entities implement security measures to guard against unauthorized access to electronic protected health information, which includes ensuring secure configurations of network devices.
Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council (FFIEC): The FFIEC IT Examination Handbook advises financial institutions to conduct regular security assessments, including reviews of network device configurations, to identify and mitigate vulnerabilities.

Benefits of Third-Party Configuration Reviews

Engaging third-party assessors for network configuration reviews offers several advantages:

Unbiased Evaluation: External assessors provide an impartial perspective, identifying vulnerabilities and misconfigurations that internal teams might overlook due to familiarity or cognitive biases.
Expertise and Experience: Third-party professionals often possess specialized knowledge and experience across various industries and technologies, enabling them to apply best practices and identify emerging threats.
Regulatory Compliance: Regular third-party assessments demonstrate due diligence and proactive risk management, which are critical components of regulatory compliance.

How MicroSolved and MachineTruth Global Configuration Assessments Can Help

Organizations looking to enhance the security and compliance of their network configurations can leverage the expertise of
MicroSolved and the MachineTruth Global Configuration Assessment service.

Comprehensive Configuration Analysis: MachineTruth provides deep visibility into router, switch, and wireless configurations across global networks, identifying misconfigurations, vulnerabilities, and deviations from industry best practices.
Automated and Manual Review: The service combines advanced automation with expert human analysis to ensure configurations align with regulatory requirements and security standards.
Customized Reporting: Organizations receive detailed reports outlining security gaps, compliance risks, and actionable remediation steps to enhance network resilience.
Continuous Monitoring and Assessments: MachineTruth enables organizations to move beyond point-in-time reviews by establishing continuous assessment cycles, ensuring that networks remain secure over time.
Global Coverage: Designed for enterprises with complex, distributed networks, the solution scales to assess configurations across multiple locations, helping organizations maintain security and compliance on a global scale.

By partnering with MicroSolved and leveraging MachineTruth, organizations can proactively secure their network infrastructure,
maintain compliance, and reduce the risk of misconfigurations leading to breaches. Regular third-party configuration assessments
are not just a regulatory requirement—they are a critical component of modern cybersecurity strategy.

* AI tools were used as a research assistant for this content.

What to Expect During a Tabletop Exercise with MicroSolved, Inc.

Posted on December 16, 2024 by Brent Huston

When it comes to organizational resilience, preparedness is everything. At MicroSolved, Inc., we specialize in helping organizations refine their incident response capabilities through tailored tabletop exercises. These sessions are designed not just to test your response to potential threats but to actively improve your readiness, team cohesion, and ability to adapt to evolving risks. In this blog, we’ll walk through what you can expect during one of our tabletop engagements and why they’re a critical component of any security strategy.

Tabletop3

Purpose of a Tabletop Exercise

Tabletop exercises are immersive, scenario-driven simulations designed to prepare organizations for real-world incidents such as cyberattacks, data breaches, or disasters. Conducted in a safe, non-disruptive environment, these sessions serve multiple purposes:

Gap Identification: Uncover weaknesses in policies, procedures, and team readiness that could hinder your response during an actual incident.
Real-World Preparation: Test your team’s ability to make decisions under pressure in a controlled, simulated crisis.
Collaboration and Alignment: Strengthen coordination between departments, clarify roles and responsibilities, and align processes with industry best practices.

By the end of the exercise, participants gain greater confidence in their ability to navigate crises while leadership obtains actionable insights to strengthen their organizational defenses.

Pre-Engagement Preparation

A successful tabletop exercise begins long before the scenario unfolds. At MicroSolved, we follow a detailed pre-engagement process to ensure the exercise is meaningful and effective:

Scoping: Every organization faces unique risks. That’s why we work closely with our clients to define the scope of the exercise and identify realistic scenarios tailored to their industry, threat landscape, and goals.
Document Review: Our experts analyze existing policies, procedures, and technical systems to ensure the exercise reflects your organization’s current capabilities and areas for growth.
Scenario Design: We take a collaborative approach to crafting scenarios. With client input, we develop challenges that are practical, relevant, and aligned with real-world threats. Our goal is to create an experience that is engaging and impactful for participants while addressing critical areas of concern.

This meticulous preparation ensures that your tabletop exercise delivers maximum value.

During the Exercise

When it’s time to step into the exercise, our team facilitates an interactive, thought-provoking simulation designed to engage and challenge your organization. Here’s what you can expect during the session:

Moderated Simulation: One of our experienced facilitators will guide participants through the scenario, posing dynamic challenges and ensuring the exercise stays focused and productive.
Role Assignments: Key personnel take on roles relevant to the exercise, such as members of the incident response, legal, communications, or executive teams. This approach reinforces accountability and helps participants better understand their responsibilities in a real crisis.
Injects: To keep participants on their toes, we introduce “injects” — unexpected developments such as new threat intelligence or complications. These injects test your team’s ability to adapt and make decisions as the situation evolves.

Our facilitation style encourages active participation, collaboration, and critical thinking, making the exercise both realistic and engaging.

Post-Exercise Debrief

The learning doesn’t stop when the scenario ends. In fact, the post-exercise debrief is where much of the value is realized. After the simulation, we guide participants through a structured review process that includes:

Immediate Feedback: Moderators and observers provide initial insights into the team’s performance, highlighting strengths and areas for improvement.
Gap Analysis: We identify specific gaps in your processes, tools, or training that may hinder your incident response capabilities.
Deliverables: MicroSolved provides a comprehensive report summarizing observations, findings, and actionable recommendations. This deliverable serves as a roadmap for improving your organization’s readiness and resilience.

Benefits to Your Organization

Tabletop exercises are more than just training sessions — they are investments in your organization’s security posture and resilience. By working with MicroSolved, your organization can expect the following benefits:

Improved Incident Response: Develop confidence and competence in responding to a variety of incidents, from cyberattacks to natural disasters.
Clarity of Roles and Responsibilities: Ensure that every team member understands their role during a crisis, reducing confusion and delays.
Alignment with Best Practices: Strengthen alignment with industry standards, regulatory requirements, and proven best practices.
Enhanced Resilience: Build your organization’s capacity to adapt, respond, and recover from incidents with minimal disruption.

Why Choose MicroSolved?

At MicroSolved, we bring decades of experience and a deep understanding of the evolving threat landscape to every engagement. Our proprietary tools and methodologies ensure that each tabletop exercise is tailored to your organization’s unique needs, providing insights and recommendations that are both actionable and practical. We pride ourselves on our collaborative approach, ensuring that your team feels supported and empowered throughout the process.

Ready to Get Started?

A well-executed tabletop exercise can make the difference between a chaotic crisis response and a confident, coordinated recovery. If you’re ready to strengthen your organization’s readiness and resilience, contact MicroSolved today to schedule a tabletop engagement.

Learn More About MicroSolved’s Approach

Let’s build resilience, one scenario at a time.

* AI tools were used as a research assistant for this content.

The Value Proposition of MSI Tabletop Exercises for Management

Posted on December 9, 2024 by Brent Huston

When it comes to cybersecurity, incident response, and business continuity planning, preparedness is key. In today’s environment, where breaches and disruptions are inevitable, organizations cannot afford to operate with untested protocols or vague plans. This is where tabletop exercises come in—providing a structured, scenario-based approach to testing and refining an organization’s readiness for real-world crises.

What Are Tabletop Exercises and Why Do They Matter?

Tabletop exercises are facilitated discussions that simulate various incident scenarios—such as cyberattacks, natural disasters, or compliance failures. These exercises aren’t just theoretical; they are practical, interactive, and designed to uncover critical weaknesses in processes and decision-making.

Testing Readiness: Evaluate whether your incident response policies and protocols stand up under stress.
Identifying Gaps: Highlight vulnerabilities in coordination, communication, or technical measures.
Enhancing Team Skills: Empower teams to handle crises with confidence and clarity.
Supporting Compliance: Meet regulatory requirements and best practices, reducing audit-related headaches.

What Sets MSI’s Tabletop Exercises Apart?

MSI has been at the forefront of cybersecurity and risk management for decades. Its proprietary approach to tabletop exercises goes beyond generic templates, ensuring real value for your organization.

Why MSI?

Customization: MSI doesn’t believe in one-size-fits-all. Each exercise is meticulously tailored to your organization’s unique risk profile, environment, and industry challenges.
Expert Facilitation: Exercises are led by cybersecurity professionals with decades of experience in managing incidents across industries.
Comprehensive Analysis: Immediate feedback during the exercise, coupled with detailed post-event reports, ensures that you walk away with actionable insights.
Collaborative Approach: MSI partners with your team at every step—from scoping and design to execution and review—ensuring the exercise aligns with your strategic goals.

How Do Tabletop Exercises Benefit Management?

While tabletop exercises are valuable for all participants, they provide specific and strategic benefits to management teams:

Preparedness: Demonstrate to boards, stakeholders, and customers that your organization is ready to handle crises effectively.
Strategic Alignment: Ensure that incident response strategies support overarching business goals.
Resource Prioritization: Identify areas requiring immediate investment, whether in tools, policies, or training.
Decision-Making Practice: Equip executives to make informed, timely decisions under high-pressure conditions.

What Scenarios Can MSI Simulate?

MSI’s exercises are designed to address a wide array of potential threats, including but not limited to:

Cyberattacks: Ransomware, phishing, or data breach scenarios.
Business Continuity Disruptions: Power outages, supply chain failures, or natural disasters.
Compliance Failures: Simulated regulatory audits or legal challenges.
Insider Threats: Scenarios involving social engineering, sabotage, or employee-related risks.

Turning Lessons into Action

The value of a tabletop exercise lies in its outcomes, and MSI ensures that every exercise delivers actionable results.

Real-Time Reviews: MSI conducts immediate debriefs to capture insights from participants.
Gap Analysis: A detailed review identifies weaknesses and opportunities for improvement.
Actionable Deliverables: You receive a written report outlining findings, recommended mitigations, and next steps to bolster resilience.

The ROI of Tabletop Exercises

While the upfront investment in tabletop exercises may seem daunting, the return on investment (ROI) is significant:

Faster Incident Response: Reduce the time it takes to contain and recover from an incident, minimizing financial and reputational losses.
Regulatory Compliance: Avoid costly fines by demonstrating proactive governance and compliance readiness.
Improved Collaboration: Strengthen team cohesion and reduce errors during real-world incidents.

Ultimately, these exercises save your organization time, money, and stress—while enhancing its overall resilience.

Take Action: Build Resilience Today

Preparedness isn’t just a buzzword—it’s a competitive advantage. MSI’s tabletop exercises are designed to give your organization the tools, confidence, and insights needed to face any challenge.

Don’t wait for a crisis to test your readiness. Contact MSI today at info@microsolved.com or visit microsolved.com to learn more about how tabletop exercises can transform your incident response strategy.

Let’s build resilience together.

* AI tools were used as a research assistant for this content.

Success of Our vCISO Program in a Credit Union Client

Posted on May 22, 2024 by Brent Huston

Our vCISO program recently celebrated a significant success with one of our credit union clients, demonstrating the profound impact of our tailored security strategies and expert guidance.

From the onset, we approached the partnership with a comprehensive risk assessment, focusing on the unique needs and regulatory requirements of the credit union sector. Leveraging our deep understanding of financial services and compliance, we crafted a robust security roadmap aligned with the NCUA ISE and CIS CSC guidelines. This foundational work set the stage for a series of strategic implementations and continuous improvements.

Key Components of Our Success

A key component of our success was the execution of tailored table-top exercises, as outlined in our proprietary workflow. These exercises simulated various incident scenarios, enabling the credit union’s team to refine their incident response protocols and improve their readiness for potential cyber threats. Our iterative approach ensured that the scenarios were realistic and relevant, leading to significant enhancements in their incident management capabilities.

Moreover, our ongoing advisory services included regular reviews and updates to their security policies and procedures, ensuring alignment with best practices and regulatory standards. This proactive stance not only fortified their security posture but also provided assurance to their stakeholders about the integrity of their financial processes.

We also prioritized the implementation of advanced threat detection and response mechanisms. Utilizing our HoneyPoint™ Security Server, the credit union achieved real-time threat intelligence and a deeper understanding of their network security landscape. This capability was crucial in detecting and mitigating threats before they could escalate into significant incidents.

One of the standout achievements was the credit union’s enhanced resilience against ransomware attacks, a prevalent threat in the financial sector. Our detailed ransomware preparedness checklist guided their implementation of critical controls, from regular data backups to comprehensive user education on phishing risks. This multi-layered defense strategy significantly reduced their vulnerability to such attacks.

Conclusion

The success of this engagement underscores the value of our vCISO program. By combining strategic oversight, hands-on exercises, and continuous improvement initiatives, we enabled our credit union client to not only meet but exceed their security and compliance objectives. This partnership exemplifies our commitment to empowering clients with the tools and knowledge necessary to navigate the complex cybersecurity landscape effectively.

To learn more about how our vCISO program can transform your organization’s security posture, visit our blog at stateofsecurity.com or contact MicroSolved directly. Together, we can build a more secure future.

* AI tools were used as a research assistant for this content.

Ransomware-Proof Your Credit Union: A Checklist of NCUA Guidance

Posted on February 13, 2024 by Brent Huston

In today’s digital landscape, credit unions face numerous cybersecurity threats, including the rising risk of ransomware attacks and vulnerabilities in their information and communications technology supply chain. To help credit unions protect themselves against these risks, the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) has compiled an FAQ. This checklist covers the essential steps to safeguard against ransomware attacks, additional resources for cybersecurity, understanding supply chain risk management, developing effective practices, mitigating risks associated with using a Managed Service Provider (MSP), and other insights based on their FAQ. By following this checklist, credit unions can enhance their overall security posture and minimize the potential impact of cyber threats.

1. Protect against ransomware attacks:
– Update software and operating systems regularly with the latest patches.
– Avoid clicking on links or opening attachments in unsolicited emails.
– Follow safe browsing practices.
– Replace equipment running older unsupported operating systems.
– Verify the security practices of vendors and third-party service providers.
– Maintain complete and tested backups of critical systems and data.

2. Additional resources for cybersecurity:
– Use the Ransomware Self-Assessment Tool (R-SAT) from the Conference of State Bank Supervisors.
– Read the Center for Internet Security white paper on ransomware.
– Visit the cybersecurity pages of the National Security Agency Central Security Service and the Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency. (CISA)
– Refer to the Treasury Department’s advisory on potential sanctions risks for facilitating ransomware payments.

3. Understand Technology Supply Chain Risk Management (SCRM):
– Recognize that technology supply chain vulnerabilities can pose risks to the entire institution.
– Consider the risks associated with third-party vendors and the entire technology supply chain.
– Identify vulnerabilities in all phases of the product life cycle.

4. Develop an effective Technology Supply Chain Risk Management Practice:
– Build a team with representatives from various roles and functions.
– Document policies and procedures based on industry standards and best practices.
– Create a list of technology components and understand their criticality and remote access capability.
– Identify suppliers and verify their security practices.
– Assess and evaluate the SCRM program regularly.

5. Risks associated with using a Managed Service Provider (MSP):
– APT actors actively attempt to infiltrate IT service provider networks.
– Conduct proper due diligence and ongoing monitoring of MSPs.
– Understand the risks of centralizing information with an MSP.
– Recognize that compromises in an MSP’s network can have cascading effects.

6. Mitigate the risk of using an MSP:
– Manage supply chain risk by working with the MSP to address security concerns.
– Implement architecture measures to restrict access and protect networks.
– Use dedicated VPNs for MSP connections and restrict VPN traffic.
– Ensure proper authentication, authorization, and accounting practices.
– Implement operational controls, such as continuous monitoring and software updates.

7. Additional references for Information and Communications Technology Supply Chain Risk Management:
– Refer to guidance from the NCUA, NIST, and CISA.
– Evaluate third-party relationships and outsourcing technology services.
– Learn about supply chain threats and cyber supply chain risk management.

Note: This checklist is a summary of the information provided. For more detailed guidance, refer to the full content on the NCUA website.

* We used some AI tools to gather the information for this article.

Closing the CUSO Security Loop Hole

Posted on September 8, 2020 by Brent Huston

The CUSO Security Loop Hole

The NCUA Inspector General (IG) suggested this week that the agency have regulatory oversight of Credit Union Service Organizations (CUSOs) to reduce the overall risk to the system. CUSOs have long been seen as a separate firm from the credit unions, though they may have an ownership stake in them. To date, many of these organizations have been outside the regulatory and oversight controls that are applied to the very credit unions they serve. In terms of information security, that often means they aren’t held to the same level of security and risk management controls as required by NCUA 748 and other guidance.

CUSO Security Oversight Challenges

The NCUA IG suggests that NCUA guidance and regulatory oversight be directly applied to CUSOs, instead of through vendor or partner risk management programs of the CUSO customers. This would provide for more direct regulation of the security controls and risk management processes in use at the CUSOs themselves. However, this introduces several challenges for some CUSOs, who may be more focused on agility, market speeds and innovation – areas where regulatory guidance can be especially impactful and can create significant budgetary challenges. This gets even more complicated when regulatory guidance is vague, or can be inflexible – the very opposite of the needs of organizations focused on innovation and market speed adaptation. An excellent example of this is CUSOs working on financial technologies, crypto currencies, blockchain and other exciting new areas. Regulatory guidance lags or lacks in most of those areas and hasn’t caught up to these new, and in some cases, experimental technologies.

One Approach – Best Practices CUSO Security and Third Party Attestation

One approach that might work, is for CUSOs to work with independent third-party assessors who could then measure the CUSO against industry standard best practices that apply to their specific lines of business, research or innovation. These vendors could then help the CUSO build a relevant and respectable CUSO security and risk management program – which they could attest to the NCUA. If this attestation were required on a yearly basis, along with some basic guidance, like ongoing risk management reviews, ongoing vulnerability management, etc – this could go a long way to mitigating the risks that concern the NCUA IG, while still maintaining independence and control by the CUSOs – thus, empowering their mission. Programs like these have been very successful in other industries and don’t have to add the overhead and bureaucracy of full regulatory compliance or programs like PCI-DSS.

If you’d like to build such a program for your CUSO, please get in touch with us. We’d love to work on creating this process with a handful of CUSOs around the US, and are more than capable of applying our 30 years of experience in information security to each organization’s independent needs. Drop us a line or give us a call at (614) 351-1237 and let’s work together to close the CUSO Security loop hole in a way that reduces risk but doesn’t destroy the power and flexibility of the CUSO ecosystem.

Three Things I’ve Learned About Credit Union Risk Management

Posted on August 10, 2020 by Brent Huston

I have been working with Credit Unions for more than 20 years and have done a wide variety of information security and risk management work over that time. I’ve worked with technical teams, management and boards over the span of more than two decades. Here are three things I’ve learned about how CUs manage risk during that time.

1) Most credit unions that I’ve worked with care just as much, if not more, about information security than most of the regional size banks they often compete with.

I’ve heard more than one CU leader tell me that they have to be better than the banks, because when a bank gets hacked – that bank makes the news and feels the impact. However, he said, when a credit union gets hacked – all credit unions suffer from the bad press. I am not sure the data supports his claim, but it’s an example of how CUs often focus on working together to solve big problems, and put a lot more attention to detail into it.

2) Many of the credit unions I have worked with look at information security and threat awareness as something that they can offer to their members (“customers, in bank speak”).

More than a few of the CUs have engaged so deeply with their customers on phishing and identify theft, that they include them in discussions about what products and services the CU buys. They do trials, include members in beta-tests and I’ve even seen them do onsite training for how to use new multi-factor authentication tools – even ones that weren’t in use at the CU – just to help make the members more secure and reduce the threat of password re-use across personal sites.

3) The board is often more involved in the risk management process at my CU clients than my banking clients.

The NCUA has taken a lot of steps to increase board member awareness about information security, and it often shows at credit unions. Several times a year, I am asked to present threat updates or review the information security program of a CU, specifically with a presentation to the board in mind. I am often engaged as a third party, to spend a couple of days looking at a security program and reporting to the board on it’s maturity and areas of potential improvement.

During these board sessions, it is not uncommon for the board questions to last more than an hour, after the presentation has completed. The point is, most CU boards that I have worked with are deeply engaged in thinking about risk management at the credit union.

For those of you interested in more about risk management at credit unions, here are some of the best sources, which I refer to often in my presentations:

Credit unions also face such internal risks as internal fraud, legal and regulatory noncompliance, data breaches, and injuries to staff and visitors. (boardeffect.com)
The bottom line: Figuring out the risk appetite will help guide credit unions to create realistic and measurable risk guidelines. (visibleequity.com)
We have helped Credit Unions develop risk appetite statements and risk frameworks and can work with your Credit Union to develop the documentation you require. (creditunionupdate.com)

If you’d like to learn more about MSI and our work with credit unions, just drop us a line (info@microsolved.com) or give us a call (614-351-1237) and we’d be happy to talk about how we might be able to help your credit union excel in IT risk management.

MicroSolved vCISO for Credit Unions

Posted on December 13, 2019 by Brent Huston

I recently asked MicroSolved COO, Dave Rose, to share his thoughts with all of us about the vCISO program. He has been leading the effort this last year across several credit unions and regional banks around the US. I asked him for the 3 biggest benefits an organization can expect and here is what he said:

“MicroSolved has been providing vCISO services to Credit Unions for over 20 years. Whether you are a corporate or a natural person CU, hiring MSI for vCISO Services will allow you to:

Obtain CISO expertise without having to incur the expense of finding and hiring a CISO. This is an affordable solution that will help keep the risk budget under control.
MSI vCISO program comes with the benefit of a focus towards financial expertise and compliance. MSI has had extensive experience working with banks and credit unions on their risk programs, and have spent time educating regulators on risk events and controls.
MSI is in the business of mitigating risk. We live it everyday and our clients benefit from that experience. Our clients get to pick the risk work they want resolved and the issues they want remediated.

You will be hard pressed to find a more efficient and cost effective way to address risk issues and move the regulatory needle. Don’t bear the burden of mitigating risk alone, let MSI be a partner to help you solve your risk needs!”

—Dave Rose

For more information, give us a call at 614-351-1237 or email us at info@microsolved.com.

Follow Up to Out of Band Authentication Post

Posted on April 27, 2012 by Brent Huston

(This is a commentary follow up to my earlier post, located here.)

A couple of folks have commented on Twitter that they have a fear of using SMS for any sort of security operations. There have been discussions about the insecurity of SMS and the lack of attention to protecting the cellular network by carriers around the world. I generally disagree with blanket statements, and I would push for organizations considering SMS as a means of authentication to undertake a real risk assessment of the process before they jump in.

However, if the controls in place in the cell networks meet their appetite for risk, then I think it is a perfectly acceptable business case. It certainly beats in-band simple authentication mechanisms like “pictures of trust” and traditional login/password as a security control.

At least in SMS authentication, the attacker would usually need to have control over or access to more than one device belonging to the user. I think this helps make the risk model more acceptable for my views.

Other folks discussed how Out of Band Authentication (OOBA) has been done now successfully in many places. I agree with this. We know how to do it. There are a LOT of vendors out there who can successfully integrate, deploy and manage a solution for you. Sadly, though, there are still more than a few who are struggling to get it right or done at all. As with most things in life, it helps to do a little research. Organizations should perform due diligence on their vendors and factor vendor risks into the equation of purchases and project planning.

Lastly, a few folks commented on the fact that they, too, are running into speed bumps with deployments and logistics. Several folks echoed the sentiments of the original challenges and few offered suggestions beyond simply “doing more homework” and looking for “quickly scalable solutions”. The good news with this is that you are not alone out there. Other folks are facing AND BEATING challenges. Feel free to reach out to your peers and discuss what is and what isn’t working for them.

As per the original post, the more communication and discussion we can have amongst the community about these topics, the better off we all will be. So, discuss, seriously…

##Special thanks to the vendors that replied with case studies, references or stories about how they have done integration and deployment. There are a lot of good vendors out there with knowledge in this area. Careful review of their capabilities will help you sort them out from the less capable. Communication is key.

Thanks for reading!